Difficulty with Decision-Making: Therapy in Toronto to Help You Move Forward

Difficulty making decisions can feel exhausting, especially when even small choices seem overwhelming or impossible. While everyone experiences indecision at times, ongoing or intense difficulty with decision-making can be a sign of deeper emotional struggles, including anxiety, depression, or low self-esteem.

 

At The Cohen Clinic, we offer therapy in Toronto for difficulty with decision-making, helping you understand what’s behind your indecision, develop practical tools, and rebuild trust in your own judgement.

What Is Difficulty with Decision-Making?

Difficulty with decision-making goes beyond “being indecisive” or “bad at choosing.” It can show up as:

  • Overthinking every option

  • Feeling paralysed by “what if” scenarios

  • Avoiding decisions and hoping they resolve on their own

  • Relying heavily on others to choose for you

When this pattern becomes persistent, it can:

  • Slow down personal and professional growth

  • Strain relationships

  • Reinforce feelings of shame, inadequacy, or helplessness

In many cases, decision-making challenges are closely linked with anxiety, depression, or self-esteem and other mental health concerns. Understanding those connections is often the first step toward meaningful change.

How Anxiety Affects Decision-Making

Anxiety can make decision-making feel dangerous, as if every choice carries serious risk. People living with anxiety often experience:

  • Persistent “what if” thinking

  • Fear of making the “wrong” choice

  • Worry about how others will react

  • A strong urge to avoid or delay decisions

This overthinking – sometimes called analysis paralysis – can make everyday choices (what to wear, what to eat, how to respond to an email) feel overwhelming. For bigger decisions related to work, relationships, or life changes, anxiety may become so intense that the person shuts down or disengages completely.

 

Over time, this pattern can strengthen:

  • Avoidance

  • Self-doubt

  • A belief that “I just can’t make decisions”

Therapy can help by addressing the underlying anxiety and teaching tools to manage fear, uncertainty, and overthinking.

How Depression Contributes to Decision-Making Struggles

Depression can make it hard to care about decisions, let alone make them. When someone is experiencing depression, they may feel:

  • Low energy and motivation

  • A sense that “nothing will really make a difference”

  • Difficulty concentrating or thinking clearly (“brain fog”)

These experiences can turn even simple decisions into heavy tasks. Common patterns include:

  • Lack of motivation: Decisions feel pointless, so it’s easier not to act.

  • Hopelessness: It may feel like no choice will lead to a positive outcome.

  • Mental fog: Weighing options or processing information feels exhausting.

The Role of Self-Esteem in Decision-Making

Low self-esteem can also play a powerful role in decision-making. When someone struggles with self-worth, they may:

  • Doubt their ability to make good choices

  • Assume others “know better” than they do

  • Fear that any mistake will prove they are not good enough

 

This often leads to:

  • Fear of failure: Mistakes feel like proof of being inadequate.

  • Perfectionism: No option feels “good enough,” so decisions are delayed.

  • Over-reliance on others: Decisions are handed over to partners, friends, or colleagues, which can later lead to resentment or feeling disempowered.

The Emotional Impact of Decision-Making Challenges

When difficulty with decision-making becomes persistent, the emotional toll can be significant. People may begin to believe:

  • “There’s something wrong with me.”

  • “I always hold others back.”

  • “I can’t be trusted to make good choices.”

This can affect:

  • Relationships: Partners or loved ones may feel pressured to always decide, or may interpret indecision as disinterest.

  • Work or school: Opportunities may be missed because decisions are delayed.

  • Self-image: The person may see themselves as “incapable,” “weak,” or “too much.”

Avoiding decisions can feel like a short-term relief, but over time it often leads to regret, stagnation, and a stronger belief that change isn’t possible.

How Therapy Can Help with Decision-Making Challenges

If decision-making has become a major source of stress in your life, therapy can help you explore what’s happening beneath the surface and build new ways of approaching choices.

 

In therapy at The Cohen Clinic, you can:

Understand What’s Driving Your Indecision

A therapist can help you identify whether anxiety, depression, past experiences, or self-esteem concerns are contributing to your difficulties. Naming these patterns makes them easier to address and change.

Recognize and Manage Your Emotional Responses

Together, you can learn to notice the emotions that arise around decisions – such as fear, shame, or frustration – and develop ways to regulate them. This might include grounding techniques, self-compassion practices, or strategies to manage worry.

Challenge Unhelpful Thought Patterns

Approaches such as Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) can be helpful in shifting:

  • Catastrophizing (“If I choose wrong, everything will fall apart”)

  • Perfectionistic thinking (“There is one perfect choice and I must find it”)

  • All-or-nothing beliefs (“If I don’t make the best choice, I’ve failed”)

Build Practical Decision-Making Tools

Therapy can also focus on concrete skills, such as:

  • Breaking big decisions into smaller steps

  • Setting realistic time frames for making choices

  • Using structured decision-making tools (e.g., pros/cons lists, value-based frameworks)

  • Rehearsing how to tolerate uncertainty without shutting down

Over time, these tools can make decisions feel more manageable and less emotionally charged.

Rebuilding Trust in Your Own Judgement

A key part of this work is restoring your confidence in your ability to choose. Therapy offers space to:

  • Reflect on past decisions with more balance and less self-criticism

  • Recognize your strengths, values, and patterns of good judgement

  • Practice making smaller, low-risk decisions and building up from there

The goal is not to eliminate uncertainty, but to help you feel more capable and grounded when making choices in your life.

Decision-Making Therapy at The Cohen Clinic in Toronto

At The Cohen Clinic, we offer therapy for difficulty with decision-making in Toronto, tailored to your unique experiences and needs. Our clinicians draw on evidence-based approaches such as CBT, emotion-focused work, and self-compassion–based strategies to help you:

  • Understand the emotional roots of your indecision

  • Reduce anxiety, depression, and self-criticism connected to choices

  • Build practical skills to make decisions with more clarity and confidence

Whether you’re struggling with day-to-day choices or larger life decisions, you do not have to navigate this alone.

The Difficulty with Decision-Making Therapy Team

Amber

Dr. Amber Cohen

CEO

jesus

Dr. Jesus Enrique G. Saplala,

Ph.D., C.Psych. Registered Clinical PsychologistCEO

Dr. Donalea McIntyre

Ph.D., C.Psych.


Registered Clinical Psychologist

GonzaloHeadshot

Gonzalo Osorio Ruchichi

Registered Psych. Associate

Dr. Fathima Mucheth Abdul Basheer

Ph.D. (Psychologist, Supervised Practice)

Untitled design (2)

Orit Reem

M.A.
Registered Psych. Associate

Emma Harman

Registered Psych. Associate

Heather Levy

M.S.W, R.S.W
Registered Social Worker

Ron Lorenzo

M.A., M.S.W., R.S.W.
Registered Social Worker

Denisa Caceres

M.A., R.P.
Registered Psychotherapist

Chelsie Ostrega

M.A., R.P.
Registered Psychotherapist

Kristin Michie

MPsy Registered Psychotherapist (Qualifying)

Carmel Laniado

M.S.W, R.S.W.
Registered Social Worker

Jayati

Jay Singh

M.A., R.P.
Registered Psychotherapist

AnetMor

Anet Mor

R.D., M.C., R.P. Registered Psychotherapist/ Dietitian
Anjana

Anjana Iyer

M.A., R.P. Registered Psychotherapist
NirmalNiazi

Nirmal Niazi

Psych. Associate
(Supervised Practice)

vanessa-garofalo-img

Vanessa Garofalo

M.S.W., R.S.W (She/Her) Registered Social Worker, Psychotherapist
Kajin (1)

Kajin Abdullah

Clinic Coordinator
KGHeadshot

Kate Goheen

Registered Psychotherapist
Clinical Practicum Therapist

elmaHeadshot

Elma Okanovic

Clinic Administrator
unnamed

Nicole Maria Reji

Intake Administrator
Untitled design (3)

Cansu Ozsoy

M.A., R.P.
Registered Psychotherapist (Qualifying)

Book Therapy for Difficulty with Decision-Making in Toronto

If decision-making feels overwhelming or is keeping you from moving forward, reaching out for support is a meaningful step.

 

At The Cohen Clinic, we’re here to help you understand what’s behind your indecision and develop tools that make choices feel less daunting and more empowering.

 

Book an Appointment today to begin therapy for difficulty with decision-making in Toronto.